Liberty USA 30
Highest score of the 15: 12-gauge steel, a 60-minute fire rating, UL listed + CA DOJ.
9.3/10Excellent$1,969Nov 13, 2026

15 safes scored on dated US prices, steel, fire rating, lock and approvals. Our No. 1 costs $1,969; the cheapest, $170.
Highest score of the 15: 12-gauge steel, a 60-minute fire rating, UL listed + CA DOJ.
9.3/10Excellent$1,969Nov 13, 2026
First of our budget ranking: $829 for 14-gauge steel and a 40-minute fire rating.
8.7/10Very good$829Nov 13, 2026
First of our handgun ranking: fingerprint + keypad + key access, 2 mm steel, $299.99.
8.8/10Very good$299.99Nov 13, 2026
First of our apartment ranking: 60.5 lb, fingerprint + keypad + key access, $399.
8.9/10Very good$399$479Nov 13, 2026
Prices checked November 13, 2026 at each US seller. Scores come from one public formula; fire ratings are the brands' own figures.
Best for a family collection of long guns that needs one serious safe for the next twenty years.
The catch: It is 565 lb and needs a 24-inch doorway, so the delivery matters as much as the safe, and Liberty prices it at checkout. The page also names the lock two ways: "Securam Toplit" in the security list and "S&G Spartan" in the lock selector. We quote the selector, since that is what you order. And 60 minutes at 1200°F is a gentler test than the 1400°F Winchester and Rhino quote.
$1,969
At Liberty Safe, checked November 13, 2026
Check price at Liberty SafeRead reviewBest for a large mixed collection that needs depth, a stated RSC listing and a replacement guarantee.
The catch: Returns go through customer service with an approval number, and the policy page prints no window in days, so you don't know your deadline before you buy. It ships within the contiguous United States only. At 594 lb it is the heaviest safe we rank whose weight we could read, and 25 inches of depth will not suit every closet. The 35-gun figure also depends on Winchester's GunStiXX rods.
$1,899.99
At Winchester Safes, checked November 13, 2026
Check price at Winchester SafesRead reviewBest for a large collection that needs room to grow, a stated RSC listing and lights that come on by themselves.
The catch: Sending it back is expensive: Rhino's policy gives 45 days from the ship date, minus a 20% restocking fee and the shipping both ways. On a $2,449 safe that is close to $500 before freight, so measure twice. The page gives no count of locking bolts and no interior dimensions, and "41 long guns" is the brochure figure. Delivery is curbside, about 2 to 4 weeks out.
Best for one home-defense long gun kept locked under the bed, plus a handgun or two.
The catch: It is a one-gun answer: a single long gun up to 44 inches, flat on a foam pad. SecureIt's FAQ says the Model 47D "should only be used horizontally", so it will not double as an upright locker. Sixteen-gauge steel is thin, there is no fire rating, and the page states no UL or California DOJ approval. At 60.5 lb it must be anchored through its pre-drilled holes, or it can leave with whoever finds it.
Best for a desk or the side of a nightstand: one handgun stored upright behind a fingerprint lock.
The catch: The warranty is 1 year, the shortest stated term on our list, and Barska's page gave us no return window. The keypad stores a single PIN, where others store several. Barska's own table says "Fireproof: No". It holds one standard-size handgun and nothing else, the 4 AA batteries are not included, and the page gives no interior dimensions, so check that your handgun fits.
Best for a first real safe for a dozen long guns, without spending four figures.
The catch: The body is 14-gauge steel, thinner than the 12-gauge that California's regulatory standard asks of a single-walled gun safe (the standard gives other ways to qualify, and Liberty does state DOJ approval), and the page gives no UL Residential Security Container listing. Liberty's fire figure is also printed two ways on the same page: 40 minutes at 1200°F in the product text, 30 minutes in the comparison table. And "24 long guns" is a brochure count: plan on fewer.
Best for a bedside or desk-drawer handgun safe you can open four ways and check from your phone.
The catch: Sixteen-gauge steel is about 1.5 mm: fine against hands and a screwdriver's first try, modest against real tools. At 7.2 lb the safe must be cabled or screwed down. The page we read states no California DOJ approval for the 20 Series, the 3 AAA batteries are not included, and the Nano Key fob is sold separately. The cheaper Essential version ($259.99) drops WiFi and stores 20 fingerprints instead of 80.
Best for anyone who wants a bedside handgun safe with no batteries, no app and a lot of steel.
The catch: There is one way in: the push-button code. Fort Knox quotes "over 1000 possible combinations", far fewer than a digital keypad offers, so pick a code that isn't a child's first guess. There is no key, no light inside and no cable; at 22 lb it should be bolted down. The page gives no return window and no California DOJ statement.
Best for owners who rank fire protection first and want a branded 12-gauge safe under $1,700.
The catch: Two blanks. The spec list describes how the lock is protected (triple-steel hard plates, hardened pins) but not which lock is fitted, and Browning's warranty page gave us no readable term. Delivery is also a real line on the bill: $449 to a main floor or garage, $549 with stairs. And the "UL Listed" line does not say Residential Security Container, so we score it one notch below a stated RSC listing.
Best for buyers who want 12-gauge steel and a 60-minute fire rating for well under $1,500.
The catch: The policy pages on steelwatergunsafes.com answered "Access Denied" when we read the site, so the warranty length, the return window and the shipping terms are blanks in our data, and blanks score low. The page claims no UL listing for the body or the lock. At 18 inches deep outside it is also the shallowest full-size safe here: fine for shotguns, tight for scoped rifles.
Fingerprint + keypad + key · 115 lb
8.1/10Good$699$799Nov 13, 2026
14-gauge steel · Fingerprint + keypad + key + phone app · 93 lb
7.8/10Fair$1,699.99Nov 13, 2026
| Safe | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 30 long guns (claimed) | 35 long guns (claimed) | 41 long guns (claimed) | 1 long gun (claimed) | 1 handgun | 24 long guns (claimed) |
| Body steel | 12-gauge steel | 12-gauge steel | 12-gauge steel | 16-gauge steel | 2 mm steel | 14-gauge steel |
| Fire rating | 60 min at 1,200°F (brand's claim) | 60 min at 1,400°F (brand's claim) | 60 min at 1,400°F (brand's claim) | No rating claimed | Not fire rated | 40 min at 1,200°F (brand's claim) |
| Ways to open | Keypad | Keypad | Keypad | Fingerprint + Keypad + Key | Fingerprint + Keypad + Key | Keypad |
| Approvals stated | UL listed + CA DOJ | UL RSC + CA DOJ | UL RSC + CA DOJ | None stated | CA DOJ | CA DOJ |
| Weight | 565 lb | 594 lb | 536 lb | 60.5 lb | 8.6 lb | 375 lb |
| Warranty | Lifetime | Lifetime | Lifetime | Lifetime | 1-year | Lifetime |
| Sold by | Liberty Safe | Winchester Safes | Rhino | SecureIt | Barska | Liberty Safe |
| Where to buy | Check price at Liberty Safe | Check price at Winchester Safes | Check price at Rhino | Check price at SecureIt | Check price at Barska | Check price at Liberty Safe |
✓ marks the best figure of the row. "Not stated" means the seller's page doesn't give it. Fire ratings and capacities are each brand's own claims; capacity is not scored. Prices checked November 13, 2026.
Biometric6 fingerprint safes · No. 1: Fast Box 47D
Fire rated7 fire-rated safes · No. 1: Sporter 23
Handgun and bedside5 handgun safes · No. 1: Barska AX13092
Rifles and long guns9 long-gun safes · No. 1: Ranger 26
Budget, under $1,5004 budget safes · No. 1: Centurion 24
American made4 American-made safes · No. 1: USA 30
For an apartment3 light cabinets · No. 1: Fast Box 47D
Every safe gets one score out of 10 from what its seller puts in writing. A blank on the page scores low, and claimed gun capacity is not scored at all.
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad
9.3/10Excellent$1,969Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad
9.2/10Excellent$1,899.99Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad
9.1/10Excellent$2,449Nov 13, 2026
16-gauge steel · Fingerprint + keypad + key · 60.5 lb
8.9/10Very good$399$479Nov 13, 2026
2 mm steel · Fingerprint + keypad + key · 8.6 lb
8.8/10Very good$299.99Nov 13, 2026
14-gauge steel · 40 min fire rating · Keypad
8.7/10Very good$829Nov 13, 2026
16-gauge steel · Fingerprint + keypad + key + phone app · 7.2 lb
8.6/10Very good$312.99Nov 13, 2026
10-gauge steel · Push-button mechanical · 22 lb
8.5/10Very good$299$345Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 95 min fire rating · 530 lb
8.4/10Good$1,649Nov 13, 2026
12-gauge steel · 60 min fire rating · Keypad + key
8.3/10Good$1,399Nov 13, 2026
Fingerprint + keypad + key · 115 lb
8.1/10Good$699$799Nov 13, 2026
14-gauge steel · Fingerprint + keypad + key + phone app · 93 lb
7.8/10Fair$1,699.99Nov 13, 2026

Price, steel, fire rating, lock, approvals, weight and warranty in one table.
A gun safe has three jobs: keep children and visitors away from firearms, slow down a thief, and give the contents a chance in a house fire. No safe does all three perfectly, and none is fireproof or impossible to open, whatever the brochure says. So we read the US product pages of 15 current safes, from a $170 travel case to a $2,759 vault built to order, noted each price at the seller on November 13, 2026, and scored them with one public formula: price, steel thickness, fire rating, lock, published approvals, and warranty.
Start with what you own. For a collection of rifles and shotguns, a full-size safe in 12-gauge steel with a 60-minute rating is the sensible floor: our No. 1, the Liberty USA 30 ($1,969), puts every claim in writing, and the Liberty Centurion 24 does a lighter version of the job for $829. For one handgun by the bed, a quick-access box is the right tool: the Barska AX13092 leads that group. If you rent or live upstairs, a 500 lb safe is not coming up the stairs, and a light cabinet such as the SecureIt Agile 52 is the honest alternative. One note before the list: fire ratings and capacities are the brands' own figures, quoted as written. Storage laws differ from state to state; nothing here is legal advice.
By Grant Holloway, editor, gun safes · updated November 13, 2026 · 15 safes from 10 brands